Gakuen Mafia EP01-EP03 [ENG SUB]

I feel like it'd take a really inexperienced mafia to panic and recruit unstrategically. I can't think of a team of six players from our player list who would collectively freak out to the extent that they'd impulse pull the trigger.

Flavor text makes me think it's recruiting and not a turncoat but I'm not sure how much stock we can put into flavor text since half the flavor text is out of context quotes from thread and the other half is silly animu drama mystery. (And I asked alca and she won't confirm what flavor is and isn't relevant. Which maybe implies that flavor that is relevant does exist.)

I do really like that we're discussing this, but I'm also not really sure how to move forward with this discussion. Like, how are we supposed to figure out the recruitment method, and even if we did figure it out, unless it really is a relationship ability, how are we supposed to figure out who maf recruited? I don't think we should completely disregard all reads from N0/D1 because even if anybody could have swapped over it's still only one person and the rest of the reads are still valid (even if we don't know which ones they are.)

Here's my unhelpful two cents.

The Facts:

Hints and claims:

Relationships:

n★utilus wrote:I think the problem is that it happened during the day phase, unless it was delayed - making it untraceable unless someone's some kind of day watcher and is aware of what goes on during the day. Auugh.

Oh man, this didn't occur to me at all. This could be the actual reason, and makes a lot more sense to me than "mafia panicked."

Okay double-post but. Barring all conversion shenanigans, which I can't do anything about except to add a big disclaimer atop all my posts:

I don't think these people are mafia:

• T3tsuya
  
• high seraph
  

N0 NK target, for what it's worth:

• Kiyoko
  

Didn't send in the NK on N0:

• Kotakia
  
• kiku
  
• deo
  
• chinomi
  

Not inclined to vote:

• nautilus - This is a really stupid reason but nautilus and I have this silly tacit agreement to let each other live when one of us is mafia so I'll start suspecting her if we're both alive come like N3 and I'm sure she'll be doing the same. (Clarification edit: I don't think she's maf because for meta reasons I don't think she'd let maf NK me on N0)
  
• ezreal - It's just a really gutsy move to openly throw suspicion on the N0 kill target for whatever reason, and I don't think a mafia would put themselves under the spotlight like that with no reason.
  
• Sammiya and Rasei - I agree that at least one of them should be town (though one of them could still be maf), since there's no reason for a message sending ability between two maf. I guess they could both be maf and faking this ability, but I don't find it likely.
  

I don't really have thoughts on anyone else right now.

I mean it makes a ton of sense really. Do it when you can't get caught.

I also refuse to vote for T3T and Cure.

Since Kotakia-chan dumped me (it's understandable, I was just too cute for her), I need a new relationship partner. :'( plz someone date the cutest girl in school. And even though it didn't work out between us!!! I'm not inclined to vote for her yet.

If I seem desperate, it's because my ability is twice as useful when I'm in a relationship, and I don't want to be operating under maximum efficiency here!

also i just re-read Disney maf and yeah that was the one we took Kiyo D1 after she had been cleared and in a PM alliance w/ alca. I bet alca is having some flashbacks to her killed kokoro w/ this as the host.

also mitsu fitsu oh my god i forgot how beautiful that whole thing was.

Kotakia wrote:also i just re-read Disney maf and yeah that was the one we took Kiyo D1 after she had been cleared and in a PM alliance w/ alca. I bet alca is having some flashbacks to her killed kokoro w/ this as the host.

Yes, holy shit. That was the game where I ruined alca's innocence and not in the suggestive innuendo way.

I'm sorry sensei please let me graduate

I really!! Hope that the recruitment role works like Lady's did in that the recruited lost their powers. Otherwise... yikes if it was say, town vig.

..................................................................... ;v;

SENSEI ARE YOU STILL UPSET

I SAID I'M SORRY

Kiyoko wrote:

But no, I'm not still upset. uvu

KIYOKO YOU KILLED HER KOKORO. YOU RUINED THAT NAIVETY. IN THE GAME OF MAFIA YOU EITHER LIE OR YOU DIE.

also tbh i'm so glad i was never as good of a player as kiyo/mitsu/feli because god damn. also t3t and luxaria are up there now too so it's going to be perma suspicion if they live to day 4.